II.
A Pack of Lies
For Jonathan Edwards & Eugene McCarthy, two
U.S.
servicemen killed in the Persian Gulf War against Iraq,
1–3 February 1991
There’s an Arab saying that when you tell
someone
that a man has died, he asks,
“Is he dead and buried or is he just dead?”
Fouad Ajami, journalist
Lie #1: That Penelope Resisted Scores of Suitors
I’m not convinced that woman wanted him
ever to come back home. She had her business
in tapestries, those three‑hour meals with men,
and Telemachus, who it’s true was dim
and narrow, some said not unlike Ulysses,
but still his mother’s toy. And after ten
or more years, don’t all lovers seem the same
in memory? One man surmounts the teeming,
well‑meaning invitations, only to pout
when she, like Hera, claims she’s not to blame
for his interminable lust and dreaming.
The man wants her to take him; she wants out
of the question of desire altogether,
on his terms. So she starts to count completely
not on Ulysses’ missing, but on facts
like ships we watch crossing against the weather
toward the world’s edge, which shimmer discretely,
then disappear when some small flick distracts
our curious eyes. You couldn’t pin her down,
not that one. Cooler to the touch than the prick
of a needle, she had mastered her delay
with vague unweavings, building her renown
on nothing but a calculated trick
to cover black and white with seamless grey,
to keep the fools like me coming around
drooling like basset hounds. It’s often so:
The facts protect the ones who want to lie
alone, while those for whom nothing is sound
muddle, splash and drown. Sometimes, though,
we also sail, blindly, into the sky. |